Two brokers, same trade, different P&L. The plan-to-plan gap is bigger than most traders' edge.
EVIDENCE LABEL — Comparison framework — uses generic plan shapes, no provider named
Brokerage marketing compares headline rates: '₹20 flat' vs '0.01%'. On a small order the flat fee wins; on a large delivery order the percentage plan wins. Which side of that crossover you trade on matters more than most strategy tweaks — because the difference repeats on every single trade.
The crossover, quantified
At ₹20 flat versus 0.01% per executed order, the break-even order value is ₹2,00,000. Equity intraday traders rarely cross it; a small-cap F&O writer routinely does. A plan that is wrong for your order profile can cost more per year than the strategy's entire expected edge. This is a solvable arithmetic problem — which is why we built the brokerage calculator rather than offering opinions.
| Order value | Flat ₹20 | 0.01% | Difference (per side) |
|---|---|---|---|
| ₹50,000 | ₹20 | ₹5 | Flat costs ₹15 more |
| ₹2,00,000 | ₹20 | ₹20 | Equal |
| ₹5,00,000 | ₹20 | ₹50 | Percentage costs ₹30 more |
Read the whole waterfall, not the headline
- Ask whether brokerage is charged per executed order or per trade — partial fills can double it.
- Check DP charges on delivery sell-side, and whether 'free' plans recover costs via higher margin rates or interest.
- Model your actual monthly turnover in a calculator — including GST on brokerage and transaction charges.
- Re-check after any plan change: charge schedules are amended more often than traders re-verify.
METHODOLOGY
Generic plan shapes (flat fee vs ad valorem) are compared across order-value bands; statutory charges layered per published bases.
LIMITATIONS
Real plans bundle additional items (DP charges, call-n-trade, margin interest). Comparisons here are structural, not an audit of any named provider.
SOURCES & CITATIONS
DISCLOSURE
This article is independent editorial analysis for information and education. It is not investment advice, a recommendation, or an offer to trade any instrument. Markets involve risk of loss; past or illustrative performance never guarantees future results.


